• Home
  • Etsy Shop
    • Bloglovin
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn

Let's Gab About Books

Good books + bookish goods

  • Home
  • Planners
    • Book Life Planner 2019
    • Bookish Life planner // free printable planner for book bloggers
    • Bullet Journal Guide + Dotted Journal + Pre-made Bullet Journal // free printables
    • Reading Notes page // Planner Add-on
  • Portfolio & Resume

ARC Review, book review, Debut Author, reviews, Uncategorized, YA • March 24, 2016

Let’s Gab About: A Fierce and Subtle Poison

img_4415

Let’s Gab

A fierce and Subtle Poison was incredibly interesting! I didn’t really know what to expect, but what I got was an intriguing story that pulled me in right away.

Samantha Mabry is a wonderful story-teller. From page one, I was drawn into the rich world of Lucas Knight, whose father builds fancy hotels in Puerto Rico. Lucas grew up spending summers on the island, which included growing up with the myths and legends told by the señoras.

The book opens up by explaining the story of a cursed girl, who is said to be deadly, full of poison, but able to grant wishes. From there, though, we follow the life of Lucas as he and the few friends he has on the island engage in questionable teenage debauchery. The story ends up being about figuring out the mystery of the disappearing girls, and how they are linked to Lucas and Isabel.

What made this story so interesting was how mystical and mysterious elements were seamlessly woven into the every day life on the island. I haven’t read a ton of magical realism, but I was so into this story that I have a feeling I will love other works from this genre!

img_4346

I started A Fierce and Subtle Poison on my way back to California from Seattle for spring break! Perfect travel read, I never felt bored!

The characters themselves felt very real to me, although we really only get much development for Lucas, Isabel, and only a little for Lucas’ friends. It was okay though, because I found this to be a story about Lucas being drawn to Isabel, his whole life, and his journey to lift the curse from the house at the end of Calle Sol.

The setting was perfect for such a dark yet whimsical story- the Caribbean island city of San Juan, Puerto Rico. It was full of hurricanes, storms, myths, curses, and ghost stories. Lucas finds that not all the stories he’s grown up hearing are pure myth, and has to confront the terrifying reality causing the disappearing girls to show up dead.

page-break-1

Overall impression:

I found this story to be wonderfully weird and darkly whimsical. I loved the writing and story telling going on in A Fierce and Subtle Poison, and was engrossed from page one! I hated every time I had to put this book down, I couldn’t wait to find out what would happen next. I somewhat expected it to be a it weirder, or to have more of the curse/myth elements, but that doesn’t mean I didn’t enjoy the story as is! I would definitely recommend this book if you want a mystical, quick read or if you’re looking for something a little out of the ordinary!

page-break-1

4 out of 5 stars to A Fierce and Subtle Poison!

4-roses

page-break-1

Have you read anything weird or mystical lately? Or have any magical realism books to recommend me? Let’s gab in the comments below!

 

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Let’s Gab About // Laura Dean Keeps Breaking Up With Me
Let’s Gab About // Drawn Together
Let’s Gab About // Front Desk by Kelly Yang
Previous
Hamilton Book Tag (GUOTS #3)
Next
Top Ten Tuesday: Recent five star reads!

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 114 other subscribers

Comments

  1. Nessa says

    March 25, 2016 at 10:57 pm

    I don’t remember anything that would pass as weird for me. But I would like to read this one, it seems interesting!!

Hello & Welcome

My name is Gabi and there is nothing I love more than stories and community. I am a library professional at the Pierce County Library System and am working on my MLIS from the UW iSchool (estimated grad 2022). My specialty is queer literature, youth literature, and graphica for youth and adults. Let me help you find your next favorite book!

In my free time, I like to design resources for other bookish folks. I also can be commissioned to do freelance brand and website design and rebranding.

  • Email
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Search

Subscribe

Join the list to receive all the latest posts!

Follow
  • Etsy Shop
  • Email me
  • Library Resume
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin

Copyright © 2026 Let's Gab About Books • Design by LuxiBee

Copyright © 2026 · Muse on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in